We the Women
Norah O'Donnell, Kate Andersen Brower
Both books explore History
Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more
A lively, eye-opening history of America's overseas territories that redraws the familiar map of the United States and shows how an empire stayed largely out of view.
Daniel Immerwahr starts from a simple observation: the map most Americans picture, with the contiguous states plus Alaska and Hawaii tucked in boxes, leaves out a great deal of land and many people the country has actually governed. From there he traces the history of the "Greater United States": the Philippines, Puerto Rico, Guam, American Samoa, scattered Pacific islands, and the many places where Washington's flag flew but citizenship, rights and attention often did not follow.
The book moves chronologically, from westward expansion and the scramble for guano-rich islands through the war of 1898, colonial rule in the Philippines and Puerto Rico, and the devastation of World War II in the Pacific. The final third makes a bigger argument: after 1945 the U.S. largely gave up formal colonies because technologies such as synthetic materials, air travel, global standards and a worldwide network of military bases let it exert power without owning much territory.
Reading it feels less like a textbook than a string of well-told stories, each one revealing something surprising, and each tied back to the central question of why so much of this history has been forgotten. Immerwahr writes with wit and a sharp eye for the odd detail, which makes nearly 400 pages pass quickly. It is a serious, well-researched work that remains accessible to readers with no background in the subject.
Immerwahr argues that the standard image of the U.S. leaves out colonies and territories that have housed millions of people. By keeping them off the mental map, Americans have been able to treat their country as a nation-state rather than an empire, and to overlook the people living under its rule without full representation.
Episodes often treated as footnotes, such as the colonial war in the Philippines, Japan's attacks across the Pacific in 1941, or the Puerto Rican nationalist movement, become central once the territories are counted. The book shows how events in these places influenced American politics, race thinking, medicine and military strategy far more than most histories admit.
Because territories sat outside the normal constraints of mainland politics, officials, doctors and soldiers could act there in ways they would not at home. Immerwahr uses this pattern to show how racial hierarchy determined who received constitutional protections and how colonial subjects were treated as both less than citizens and useful subjects of experimentation.
The book's most original claim is that after World War II, synthetic substitutes for tropical raw materials, aviation, radio, standardization and the spread of English reduced the value of holding territory. The U.S. could dominate globally through trade, culture and infrastructure, keeping only small pieces of land where needed.
Instead of large colonies, the postwar U.S. built a dotted pattern of hundreds of bases worldwide. Immerwahr presents this network as the modern, low-visibility form of American empire: tiny in land area, enormous in reach, and largely invisible to the public whose government runs it.
Because it covers so much ground, the book treats many places and episodes briefly, and specialists may find some chapters thin. Its framing is mostly from the American side, so perspectives from within the territories appear less often than critics would like. Some historians question how forgotten this empire really is, noting a long scholarly literature on it. The postwar argument about technology substituting for colonies is persuasive but more interpretive and less documented than the earlier sections. Coverage of Native American dispossession is relatively limited given its importance to the theme.
Book details and cover from Google Books.
Ready to read How to Hide an Empire?
Get your copy on Amazon, or listen to it on Audible. We earn a commission if you buy through these links.
Norah O'Donnell, Kate Andersen Brower
Both books explore History
Wendy Holden
Shares the History genre and themes
Scott F. Wolter
Another excellent History for readers interested in this subject
Plato
Shares the History genre and themes