Shutter Island
Dennis Lehane
Like Mara Dyer, it follows a protagonist whose memories and perception cannot be trusted, with eerie settings and a slow reveal of what really happened.
12 books to read next
Books Like The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer
If you loved The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer by Michelle Hodkin
The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer is a young adult thriller that blends a gothic mystery with a slow-building romance. Readers tend to love its unreliable narrator, who cannot recall the accident that killed her friends, and the steady drip of clues that makes every memory feel dangerous. The pacing is brisk, the tone is moody and suspenseful, and the supernatural elements arrive gradually rather than all at once. It suits readers who enjoy puzzles, eerie atmosphere and a heroine piecing together her own past.
Same haunting mystery
We Were Liars
E. Lockhart
A teen narrator pieces together a traumatic summer and a tragedy she cannot fully grasp, with the same secrets-and-memory tension that drives Mara's story.
Hidden
Helen Frost
A quiet, unsettling verse novel about a family's buried past, appealing to readers who liked the gradual unveiling of dark memories in Mara Dyer.
Supernatural romance with danger
Twilight
Stephenie Meyer
A teen romance tangled with a dangerous, otherworldly love interest and a heroine drawn into a world she only partly understands, much like Mara and Noah.
Beautiful Creatures
Kami Garcia, Margaret Stohl
Set in a small Southern town with a forbidden supernatural romance and family secrets, it shares the gothic atmosphere readers enjoy in Mara Dyer.
Crescendo
Becca Fitzpatrick, Becca Fritzpatrick
A dark paranormal romance where a teen falls for a mysterious boy and uncovers hidden forces, appealing to fans of Mara and Noah's intense bond.
Eerie, atmospheric reads
The Raven Boys
Maggie Stiefvater
Its brooding small-town setting, psychic undercurrents and close group of characters chasing a secret give the same moody feel that drives Mara Dyer.
Made You Up
Francesca Zappia, Amanda Ronconi
A protagonist with an unreliable grip on what is real keeps readers guessing, echoing the uncertain memories at the heart of Mara Dyer.
Dangerous girls
Abigail Haas
A dark, twisty story about a girl whose past and present blur, offering the same unsettling sense of a narrator hiding something that readers liked in Mara Dyer.
Go deeper into gothic horror
Rebecca
Daphne du Maurier
A classic gothic mystery about a haunted house and a haunting past, offering the brooding atmosphere and buried secrets that fans of Mara Dyer enjoy.
Frankenstein
Mary Shelley, Philip Pullman
A foundational gothic tale of guilt, the unnatural and a narrator tormented by what they have done, appealing to readers drawn to Mara's dark past.
The Turn of the Screw
Henry James
A chilling ghost story with an uncertain narrator and creeping dread, matching the ambiguous, eerie tension that runs through Mara Dyer.
We earn a commission if you buy through these links. Learn more