Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more
We earn a commission if you buy through these links. Learn more
Find Similar BooksA sharp, funny fairy-tale reversal that puts two mismatched best friends in the wrong schools and asks whether looks, reputation, or choices make someone good.
Every four years, two children vanish from the village of Gavaldon, taken to a hidden school that trains the heroes and villains of future fairy tales. Sophie, pretty and obsessed with becoming a princess, is sure she belongs among the Evers. Her gloomy, sharp-tongued friend Agatha seems destined for the Nevers. When the two are swapped, each must survive a school built for someone else, and the question of who truly belongs where drives the whole story.
Chainani writes with brisk energy and a wicked sense of humor. The lessons, rivalries, and school rituals parody classic fairy tales while borrowing the boarding-school appeal of Harry Potter. Underneath the spectacle, the heart of the book is the friendship between Sophie and Agatha: loyal, jealous, and frequently tested. A love triangle involving the prince Tedros adds tension without taking over.
Reading it feels like a long, eventful adventure with plenty of cliffhanger chapter endings. It is a sizable book for middle-grade readers, packed with set pieces, magical trials, and shifting loyalties, and it opens a six-book main series. Younger readers will enjoy the action and comedy; older ones will notice how the story pokes at the idea that beauty equals virtue and ugliness equals wickedness, even when it doesn't fully escape those tropes itself.
The book's central provocation is that the fairy-tale shortcut of linking beauty with goodness and ugliness with villainy is unreliable. Sophie's charm hides vanity and selfishness, while Agatha's grim exterior covers kindness and courage. Watching each girl misjudged by a school that sorts by surface encourages readers to look past image and judge people by what they actually do.
Rather than centering romance, the story makes the bond between two very different girls its emotional core. Their friendship is lopsided, competitive, and sometimes painful, and Chainani doesn't pretend it's easy. The tension between loyalty and self-interest gives the book more emotional weight than a typical magic-school romp and sets up questions the rest of the series continues to explore.
Classes, uniforms, and school traditions gleefully skewer princess etiquette and villain training, making the setting fun to explore. But the humor sits alongside real danger, cruelty, and transformation. The blend of satire and peril keeps the tone lively, letting readers laugh at fairy-tale conventions while still caring about what happens to the characters inside them.
Both girls are told who they are by others, by the village, the school, and the stories they grew up on. The plot keeps testing whether destiny is fixed or whether people can decide their own nature. It's an accessible way for young readers to think about labels, expectations, and the gap between how others see us and who we become.
Some readers find the book overlong, with a crowded middle section and plot turns that rely on convenient magic. Its critique of beauty standards is undercut at times by vivid descriptions that still equate physical ugliness with wickedness, and some feel it reinforces the gender roles it means to mock. Sophie's self-absorption grates on many readers, and the ending divides opinion. The violence and darker moments may be intense for the youngest readers in the middle-grade range.
Reviews from readers on YouTube. Their opinions are their own.
Book details and cover from Google Books.
Ready to read The School for Good and Evil?
Get your copy on Amazon, or listen to it on Audible. We earn a commission if you buy through these links.
J. K. Rowling
The classic boarding-school fantasy: sorting into houses, strange lessons and school rivalries will feel familiar to anyone who enjoyed the Schools for Good and Evil and their competing students.
Jessica Townsend
A cursed girl is whisked into a magical city and must pass trials to join an elite society, offering the same wonder, outsider heroine and secret-filled institution as Chainani's school.
Sarah Prineas
A street thief becomes an apprentice wizard in a city of magic. Like Agatha, he is an unlikely fit for his new world and must prove himself through wit and courage.
Adam Gidwitz
Hansel and Gretel wander through the real, gruesome Grimm stories with a cheeky narrator, delivering the same darkly funny, subversive take on fairy tales that makes Chainani's book so fun.
