The Unlikely Tale of Chase and Finnegan
Jasmine Warga
Both books explore Juvenile Fiction
Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more
by Drew Daywalt
A quick, silly holiday story in which the crayons try to cover for a tired Green Crayon. It works best as a light St. Patrick's Day read-aloud for young fans of the series.
This small hardcover is a seasonal spin-off of The Day the Crayons Quit, the popular picture book about crayons with strong opinions about how they get used. Here the holiday is St. Patrick's Day, the busiest time of year for Green Crayon, and he wants time off. Still worn out from a demanding Christmas, he steps back. The other crayons offer to fill in, and the comedy comes from how wrong things look without him: leprechauns, clovers and rainbows all seem to need his color.
The humor is gentle and visual. Children get to spot the mismatched colors and explain why they don't belong, which makes the book interactive when read aloud. The story stays on one idea, that every color has a job and is missed when it's gone, and it doesn't try to teach much about the holiday's history or meaning. It is a festive, color-themed giggle rather than an informational book.
This is a short book. It reads in a few minutes, which suits toddlers, preschoolers and early elementary kids at bedtime, in a classroom circle, or tucked into a holiday basket. Families who already love the crayons will recognize the personalities and the running joke about overworked colors. Newcomers can follow it without having read the original, though some of the charm builds on knowing the earlier books.
The core joke is that St. Patrick's Day belongs to Green Crayon, and nobody else can stand in for him. Kids see that when one friend is missing, the whole picture suffers. It's a light, friendly message about each member of a group mattering, delivered through colors rather than a lecture, so young listeners pick it up without being told.
Much of the fun comes from familiar St. Patrick's Day images drawn in the wrong shade, such as a blue clover. Children enjoy being the experts who notice the mistake and say what color it should be. That turns the read-aloud into a back-and-forth game and quietly reinforces color recognition for the youngest readers.
Green Crayon's request for a break carries over the series' running theme of crayons who feel overused or underappreciated. Adults may smile at a worker who is burned out after the holidays. Kids simply see a tired friend, which opens space for small talk about rest, fairness and taking turns with chores.
The book uses the trappings of St. Patrick's Day, like leprechauns, clovers and rainbows, as props for the gag rather than explaining where the holiday comes from. That keeps it breezy and universally accessible. Families wanting cultural or religious background will need to pair it with something else.
This is a slim, novelty-style holiday title, and it feels like one. The story is a single joke stretched over a few pages, so it lacks the layered letters and character variety that made the original crayon book stand out. Because it's tied to one date, it may sit on the shelf most of the year. It says almost nothing about the holiday's origins or Irish culture. Some parents see the run of seasonal spin-offs as more merchandise than storytelling. Judged as a quick, festive laugh, though, it does its job.
Book details and cover from Google Books.
Ready to read Happy St. Patrick's Day from the Crayons?
Get your copy on Amazon, or listen to it on Audible. We earn a commission if you buy through these links.
Jasmine Warga
Both books explore Juvenile Fiction
Jory John
Another excellent Juvenile Fiction for readers interested in this subject
Tui T. Sutherland
Both books explore Juvenile Fiction
Aaron Reynolds
Shares the Juvenile Fiction genre and themes