The Good Egg Hunt
Jory John
Another excellent Juvenile Fiction for readers interested in this subject
The Big Lie
by Julie Mayhew
A sheltered teenager's gradual questioning of the rules she was raised to follow makes this a sharp, uneasy read about obedience, conscience, and how ordinary people learn to live with a dictatorship.
What It's About
The Big Lie is a young adult novel set in England under a Nazi regime, but it is set in the present day rather than the 1940s, which keeps the premise uncomfortably close to home. The story is less about battles or resistance movements than about a teenager raised to comply, and about whether the virtues she has been taught still hold up once she starts to look at them honestly.
As is typical of this kind of story, the reader sees the regime mostly through one young viewpoint, so the pressure builds through small choices, quiet doubts, and the cost of stepping out of line rather than through large set pieces. It is a quick, direct read with a clear moral focus, and it asks you to notice how a society can normalize cruelty one reasonable-seeming rule at a time.
The experience is tense and reflective more than action-packed. The book also includes historical notes from the author at the end, which help connect the fiction to real events from the Second World War for readers who want more context on what the setting draws from.
Read this if you…
- want a young adult novel that takes moral questions about obedience and conscience seriously
- are interested in alternate history or what-if stories about Europe during the Second World War
- like stories where the main character's doubts build slowly rather than through constant action
Skip it if you…
- prefer fast, plot-driven adventure with frequent set pieces and twists
- want a detailed, nuanced portrait of wartime resistance or historical events rather than a fictional premise
Key Ideas
- 1
Is rule-following the same as being good?
The central question is whether obedience can count as virtue. The protagonist has been taught to be a good girl in a conventional sense, and the book tests that idea against a world where the rules themselves are unjust. It pushes the reader to ask what goodness requires when the authorities are wrong.
- 2
How ordinary life adapts to authoritarian rule
Much of the book's force comes from showing how a regime becomes routine. Small compromises and everyday habits make cruelty feel normal to those inside it. The reader watches the protagonist's world narrow, and sees how easy it is to accept limits one step at a time.
- 3
The price of breaking the rules
Rebellion here is not glamorous. The story treats defiance as risky for the protagonist and for people around her, and it asks whether personal courage is worth that cost. This makes the moral choices feel concrete rather than abstract, which is where much of the emotional tension comes from.
- 4
A present-day setting that echoes history
Placing the story in the present, rather than a distant past, makes the scenario feel closer and less like a museum piece. Readers who know the history of the 1940s will recognize the echoes, while the author's historical notes help ground the fiction in what actually happened.
Limitations
I am relying mostly on the publisher's description and general knowledge of the book, so I cannot speak confidently about its specific characters, pacing, or how its ideas are developed scene by scene. Readers who want a precise account of the plot should check a sample or other reviews. The alternate-history premise is also one that many dystopian and wartime-set novels have explored, so the book's originality may feel limited to readers who know that genre well. Its treatment of the period is shaped by the fictional frame rather than by historical scholarship, though the author's notes help with that.
Questions Readers Ask
- Who is The Big Lie best suited for?
- It is aimed at young adult readers and suits teenagers who enjoy dystopian fiction and moral questions. Adults who like YA dystopias may also find it a quick, thoughtful read. Because the themes involve a fascist regime and the cost of resistance, it works well for classroom discussion or for readers who want to talk about how societies go wrong.
- Is the book a good way to learn about the Second World War?
- It is better as a starting point than as a history. It is a fictional story set in an imagined present-day England under Nazi rule, so its events are not historical. The author's historical notes at the end can point readers toward real events and sources, which makes them a useful next step for anyone curious about the period.
- Published
- 2017
- ISBN
- 9780763691257
- Difficulty
- beginner
- Category
- Children's Books
Book details and cover from Google Books.
Ready to read The Big Lie?
Get your copy on Amazon, or listen to it on Audible. We earn a commission if you buy through these links.
You Might Also Like
The Curse Breaker
Jen Calonita
Another excellent Juvenile Fiction for readers interested in this subject
War Games
Alan Gratz
Another excellent Juvenile Fiction for readers interested in this subject
Happy St. Patrick's Day from the Crayons
Drew Daywalt
Another excellent Juvenile Fiction for readers interested in this subject