The Magicians
Lev Grossman
A bright, cynical student wins a place at a secret college of magic and finds the lessons far darker than expected. Its adult, sardonic voice echoes A Deadly Education's take on the magical boarding school.
Buy on AmazonBuy on Bookshop.orgListen on Audible
We earn a commission if you buy through these links. Learn more
Find Similar BooksA Deadly Education
by Naomi Novik
Fiction
★★★★★4.5 (2)
This dark school fantasy has a reluctant, dangerous heroine with a prickly voice, set in a magic academy where no adult will rescue you.
What It's About
A Deadly Education follows El Higgins, a teenage sorceress whose raw power frightens everyone around her, including the school that is supposed to train her. The Scholomance is a magic academy that exists in its own pocket of reality. It has no teachers in any ordinary sense, and monsters called maleficaria seep in from the ambient magic, so students spend their years fighting to reach the graduation hall alive. Students from wealthy walled enclaves get protection and backing that El lacks, which shapes everything about how she is treated.
Novik writes in a first-person voice that is sardonic, funny, and bleak in equal measure. The jokes take the edge off the gore without making the danger feel fake. The world is built through the rules of the school itself: how mana works, why certain choices matter, and what the place expects from its students. The dark academia flavor comes from rigid hierarchies, cliques, and the way ambition and fear feed each other.
Reading it feels like being pulled through a tense, often claustrophobic obstacle course with a narrator who refuses to be easy to like or easy to dismiss. The pace is brisk, the stakes feel personal, and the friendships and rivalries carry real emotional weight. It works as a complete novel, though it is clearly the opening of a trilogy and leaves threads open for the sequels.
Read this if you…
- Enjoy dark academia with real danger and a sharp, funny narrator
- Want a fantasy heroine who is prickly, morally complicated, and not interested in being liked
- Like magic systems that come with clear rules and steep costs
Skip it if you…
- Want a cozy or whimsical school story in the vein of Hogwarts
- Dislike ongoing trilogies or need a fully resolved single volume
Key Ideas
- 1
Survival as the school's only curriculum
The Scholomance offers no safe classroom in the usual sense. The real lesson is staying alive long enough to leave, and the book keeps returning to how that pressure shapes friendships, rivalries, and every decision students make. Novik turns a familiar boarding school setting into something closer to a survival story, where ordinary school concerns like status and belonging matter only because the monsters are always nearby.
- 2
Power that others expect you to misuse
El is treated as a future dark queen before she has done anything, and the book examines what happens when a reputation becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. Her stubborn refusal to become the villain people predict gives the story its moral spine. Readers who enjoy characters who push back against the labels imposed on them will find this the book's most rewarding thread.
- 3
Class and who gets protected
Enclave students arrive with money, networks, and safety nets, while others have to fend for themselves. Novik uses this divide to show how privilege decides who survives and who is written off. The inequality is not just background texture; it drives alliances, resentments, and El's sense of what the world owes her.
- 4
A voice that carries the whole book
Much of the pleasure comes from El's narration: blunt, witty, sometimes self-deprecating, and quick to undercut its own drama. The voice makes the grim setting feel alive and gives the reader a companion through the bleaker stretches. If you read this mainly for plot, you may find the commentary more absorbing than the action.
Limitations
Some readers find the middle stretches repetitive, since much of the book is structured around the same cycle of danger, survival, and social maneuvering. The world-building rules are inventive but can feel dense early on. Orion Lake, the figure at the center of the romantic tension, divides readers; some find the dynamic compelling and others find it frustrating. The book also works as the setup for a trilogy, so it leaves major questions open and will not satisfy anyone who wants full closure from this volume alone.
Questions Readers Ask
- Is A Deadly Education a standalone novel?
- It can be read on its own and has a satisfying arc, but it is the first book of the Scholomance trilogy and leaves major threads open. The sequels are The Last Graduate and The Golden Enclaves. If you dislike cliffhanger-style endings, plan to continue with the next book or wait until you can read the series together.
- How does it compare to Harry Potter?
- Both are magic school stories, but A Deadly Education is much darker and has no benevolent adults to rely on. The danger is constant and the tone is sardonic rather than whimsical. Readers who loved the sense of wonder in Harry Potter may find this bleaker, though those who want a grittier take on the same setting will likely appreciate it.
What Creators Say About A Deadly Education
Reviews from readers on YouTube. Their opinions are their own.
- Published
- 2020
- ISBN
- 9780593128497
- Difficulty
- beginner
- Category
- Fiction
Book details and cover from Google Books.
Ready to read A Deadly Education?
Get your copy on Amazon, or listen to it on Audible. We earn a commission if you buy through these links.
Books Like A Deadly Education
View all →
Ninth House
Leigh Bardugo
A hard-edged heroine with a talent for seeing the dead is pulled into the secret magical societies of an elite university. Its dangerous campus politics and bleak humour will suit fans of Novik's Scholomance.
The Secret History
Donna Tartt
A close-knit group of classics students at an elite college makes a terrible choice and must live with it. Its atmosphere of privilege, dread and moral unease matches the dark academia feel of A Deadly Education.
Babel
R. F. Kuang, Michel Pagel
Students at an Oxford translation college learn that their studies power a system of silver-based magic. The rigorous academic setting and the cost of knowledge will appeal to readers of Novik's school story.