Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more
We earn a commission if you buy through these links. Learn more
Find Similar BooksA fast, twisty high school whodunit that uses a detention-room death to ask how much the labels teens wear hide, and what they'd risk to protect their secrets.
Five students land in detention at Bayview High, and one of them, Simon, the kid who runs a notorious gossip app, collapses and dies before it ends. Police soon decide it was no accident. Simon had damaging posts queued up about each of the other four, which turns a straight-A student, a popular girl, a baseball star and a kid on probation into suspects and then into tabloid fixtures.
Karen M. McManus tells the story through four rotating first-person narrators. Each chapter is short and usually ends on a small hook, so the pages move quickly. The setup borrows The Breakfast Club's stereotypes on purpose, then spends the book taking them apart. Each suspect turns out to have a private life far messier than their reputation, and the investigation forces them to decide whether to trust one another. Alongside the mystery are family pressure, first romance, online pile-ons and the way news coverage flattens real people into easy villains.
Reading it feels like bingeing a teen drama. The prose is plain and the dialogue is natural. It plants enough clues for attentive readers to play detective. It isn't a deep or literary book, but it is very good at making you want one more chapter, which is a big part of why it became a bestseller and spawned sequels and a TV adaptation.
Each suspect starts as a familiar type: the brain, the beauty, the criminal, the athlete. The book's real project is peeling those labels back. As the pressure builds, each character has to face how much of their public image was performance, and who they are once that image is taken away by suspicion and gossip.
Rotating viewpoints let McManus give each suspect an inner life while keeping the reader unsure who is hiding what. Every narrator withholds something, even from us, so the structure doubles as a misdirection tool. It also keeps the pace brisk, because each switch offers a fresh angle on the same crisis.
Simon's app runs on exposing classmates, and the novel asks what that does to people. Some secrets are trivial and some are deeply personal. The book draws a line between wrongdoing and private matters that nobody has a right to broadcast, and it shows how exposure can hurt people regardless of guilt.
Once the case goes public, news vans, online commenters and classmates all decide who is guilty long before the facts are in. The story uses this to show how quickly teens become characters in someone else's narrative, and how hard it is to reclaim your own story once it has gone viral.
Seasoned mystery readers often say they guessed the solution well before the end, and the four narrators can sound fairly alike. The stereotypes are deliberately broad at the start, which some find too schematic. Several reviewers also felt the resolution touches on serious subjects that deserved more careful handling, and one character's secret storyline drew debate about how it is used as a plot device. The romance subplots take up a lot of room, which helps the drama but slows the investigation. Readers wanting nuanced literary YA may find it thin.
Reviews from readers on YouTube. Their opinions are their own.
Book details and cover from Google Books.
Ready to read One of Us Is Lying?
Get your copy on Amazon, or listen to it on Audible. We earn a commission if you buy through these links.
Holly Jackson
A student reopens a closed local murder case for a school project. Like McManus's book, it's twisty, addictive and full of small-town secrets that teens uncover themselves, with clues readers can follow along.
Maureen Johnson
A true-crime-obsessed student at an elite academy digs into an old kidnapping and murder. Fans of Bayview's tangled clues will enjoy its clever mystery and witty, distinctive cast.
Jennifer Lynn Barnes
A girl inherits a billionaire's fortune and must solve puzzles among his suspicious grandsons. It offers the same fast pace, cliffhanger chapters and guessing game about who can be trusted.
Courtney Summers
Alternating between a missing girl's story and a podcast investigating her disappearance, it uses shifting perspectives like One of Us Is Lying, but with a darker, more emotional edge.
