We earn a commission if you buy through these links. Learn more
Cold comfort farm
A sharp, very funny 1932 parody of gloomy rural novels, where a supremely sensible young woman turns up at a bleak Sussex farm and refuses to take its melodrama seriously.
What It's About
Cold Comfort Farm is a comic novel from 1932 that spoofs the brooding, earthy rural fiction fashionable at the time, especially the novels of Mary Webb, with their suffering heroines and their sense that nature and fate are closing in. Stella Gibbons takes that whole tradition and plays it with a perfectly straight face, which is what makes the book so funny. The story follows Flora Poste, a capable, unflappable young woman who decides to move in with distant relatives on a remote farm and set about improving things.
The style is brisk and deadpan. The narration never winks, while the household behaves with operatic intensity, and Flora responds with practical good sense, treating every family crisis as a problem that can be managed with a plan. Much of the humour comes from precise characterisation and from the gap between how people talk about their troubles and how sensibly Flora sees them. The book moves quickly through a sequence of set pieces, and each one lands a joke.
Reading it feels light, quick and gleefully observant. It is short enough to finish in an evening or two. The satire is sharp but affectionate rather than cruel. You don't need to have read Webb to enjoy it, though some familiarity with the books being mocked makes the jokes land harder.
Read this if you…
- enjoy dry, deadpan British comedy with a strong satirical edge
- want a short, sharp novel you can finish in a weekend
- like books that poke fun at other books and their conventions
Skip it if you…
- prefer lyrical, emotionally heavy rural fiction and find parody irritating
- want a story driven by suspense or a slow-building plot
Key Ideas
- 1
Parody as the engine of the book
Gibbons takes the conventions of doom-laden rural fiction, including its storms, its fatalism and its intense family secrets, and treats them as comic material. The pleasure lies in recognising what is being sent up and seeing how far the joke can be pushed without ever breaking the deadpan tone.
- 2
Flora as the sensible outsider
Flora is the book's anchor. She is modern, pragmatic and unimpressed by inherited gloom, and her brisk reasoning exposes how absurd the household's habits are. Her confidence is itself a joke, since she is entirely comfortable spending other people's resources while being sure she is doing them good.
- 3
Comedy built from character
Each family member is an exaggerated type with a fixed manner and a fixed obsession, and the comedy comes from how consistently they play that role. Gibbons relies on repetition and timing rather than plot twists, so the characters become funnier the more often they reappear.
- 4
Privilege, work and who pays
Beneath the jokes sits a quiet interest in money, leisure and obligation. Flora's freedom from earning a living is treated lightly, but it shapes the whole story, and the book is more aware of class and dependence than its breezy surface suggests.
- 5
Mocking the cult of rural passion
Much of the book targets the romantic idea that the countryside is a place of elemental emotion and inevitable doom. Gibbons suggests that this view is as much a fashion as the books that promoted it, and she is most devastating when her characters take it most seriously.
Limitations
The satire is aimed at a 1930s literary fashion, so some of the targets, especially Mary Webb's novels, are less familiar now, and readers who have not encountered them may miss part of the joke. The characters are deliberately broad rather than psychologically deep, which some readers find thin. The book's treatment of class and rural life is affectionate but comfortable, and it is written from the viewpoint of a privileged heroine, so it does not explore the lives of the farm workers in much depth.
Questions Readers Ask
- Do I need to have read Mary Webb to enjoy Cold Comfort Farm?
- No. The book is funny on its own terms, with broad characters and a clear comic premise. Knowing the rural novels it parodies adds an extra layer, because you can spot which scenes are sending up particular conventions, but the jokes do not depend on that knowledge.
- Is Cold Comfort Farm still worth reading today?
- Yes, mainly for its comic writing and its precise sense of character. Some of the satirical targets have faded, but the deadpan voice and the sheer energy of the set pieces remain sharp. It works well as a light, quick read that still makes people laugh.
- Published
- 2020
- ISBN
- 9780369403049
- Difficulty
- beginner
- Category
- Fiction
Book details and cover from Google Books.
Ready to read Cold comfort farm?
Get your copy on Amazon, or listen to it on Audible. We earn a commission if you buy through these links.